Remember the news reports exclaiming that cheerleading is the most dangerous sport? Well, it turns out that is not true. Just goes to show you can’t believe everything you hear or read.
A new report submitted by the American Association of Cheerleading Coaches and Administrators (AACCA) challenges the assertion that cheerleading is more dangerous than sports such as football and hockey.
It seems that information derived from two sources – The National Center for Catastrophic Sports Injuries at the University of North Carolina (NCCSI) and the Consumer Product Safety Commission’s Emergency Room visit study (NEISS) was misrepresented. When it comes to statistical analysis, such misrepresentation is not unusual but in the case of cheerleading, it led to sensationalized news reports and media coverage.
What is the real story? Well, the AACCA wanted to know this too and so they conducted their own study by analyzing the data from the NCCSI study and comparing it to the “injuries per 100,000 participants” for cheerleading to the other sports discussed in the study.
You see, to determine the “danger” of an activity compared to other activities (cheerleading to football, for example), it is important to measure the actual “risk” of injury from performing the activity. This is determined by calculating the number of injuries per athletic exposure, designated as “injuries per AE.” So for each time someone engages in cheerleading or football, how often will an injury occur.
The AACCA analyzed data from the CPSC study for other traditional female sports and used participation figures provided by American Sports Data to produce a measurable risk assessment.
What did they find? Because a typical cheerleading season is longer than that for other sports (ice hockey or soccer, for example), that needed to be factored into the analysis. AACCA discovered that there are ten high school sports – including girl’s ice hockey, gymnastics, and soccer – with a higher risk of catastrophic injury than for cheerleading. There are 17 high school sports with a lower risk of catastrophic injury.
And what about football? Contrary to earlier reports, it turns out that football is the leading cause of catastrophic injury in high school and college sports, with 63.5% of all catastrophic injuries.
So why have there been an increase in emergency room visits by cheerleading? Well, for one thing, there are more and more girls and boys who are participating in the sport. Don’t forget that school-based cheerleaders only account for a portion of all cheerleaders. So when these emergency room figures were looked at again, it turns out that the incidence of cheerleading emergency room visits were lower than that of girls’ soccer, basketball and softball.
What’s the bottom line? Cheerleading is certainly not risk-free but the risks associated with it are in line with other male and female school sports and are much lower than the risks associated with football.
Of course the ideal would be for there to be no injuries in cheerleading and while that may not be possible, it certainly is possible to reduce the number of injuries that do occur.
How? All cheerleading coaches should be safety certified and should follow established safety rules. All cheerleading programs should establish and practice an emergency action plan.
As a mental game coach, I would add that a psychological readiness training program would benefit coaches and cheerleaders alike. Training in ways to enhance focus and manage distractions (which can lead to making mistakes and causing injuries) would help a great deal.